Living in a divided world
Recently I received a concerned letter about a post I made to an internet discussion forum. It was polite and compassionate. I was surprised by the warmth I felt from a person whose position is very different from my own!
I've posted my reply here, as the issue we were discussing is important and current. What do you think? You are able to comment at the end of this article. (I've only included my part of the exchange, and left out a couple of identifying details.)
Dear ......,
thank you for your interest and concern.
I cannot agree with your assessment of the situation concerning Islam.
There is no doubt we have a huge problem in today's world with militant Islam. However, I find that the attitudes expressed by even the most extreme Muslims, are little different than those expressed by the militant conservative US and Australian Christians I read, and also by some followers of Judaism. It suits our media to highlight and report the atrocities of Islam, and its extremist attitudes. Yet I find that many of those same attitudes are expressed in Christian sermons and conversations in my own city, but remain unpublished. Or, they are spouted in newsgroup discussions, but not treated with the same (appropriate) outrage that would be accorded similar sentiments from a Muslim. Indeed, the most offensive material I have ever read was in a Christian newsgroup. In [the discussions on the internet forum we belong to], the Christians are depressingly often bitter and bigoted and use violent language at a level which matches the worst of the atheists/secularists, or how ever we want to describe them.
Likewise, Christian and Jewish terrorism, such as in Serbia, Northern Ireland and Gaza etc, is not reported in the same way as that in Muslim countries, and regarded as a perversion of the faith, and somehow different from the Islamic barbarity. There is much done by Palestinians which is reprehensible and indefensible. But much of the response of Israel, over decades, is in the same league. Before Serbia and Northern Ireland, there is a long history of Christian atrocity which is conveniently ignored in our criticism of Islam.
By contrast, the piety and spirituality of two of my Muslim friends has been an inspiration to me.
Their gentleness, coming out of a war torn country is an indictment upon much of our lukewarm Christianity.
Their spirituality is part of what moved me to come back to full time ministry in the church.
As they talk of their experience of Allah, I realise we are speaking of the same God, meeting us through the filters of different history and culture.
I cannot subscribe to "Muslim bad, Christian good." Jesus says we will know people by their fruits...
Whilst you and I may feel that Islam is not the best way to seek after the one true God of our father Abraham, some of its followers show more fruit of the Spirit than many Christians.
I think we are better to seek to dialogue with, and understand, and pray with those who truly seek God, than to write off people as wrong because they are Islamic. That dialogue and prayer will include challenging some of the shortcomings we see in their religious path, but also include being challenged about our own.
I know well that the Koran, and the Islamic tradition, has sayings in it which we find offensive, and which are not acceptable attitudes for civilised humanity. But the same is true of our Hebrew scriptures. Indeed, some of the New Testament is not exactly enlightening in its attitudes. Will we cherry pick the shortcomings of other faiths to build up our own position? Will we be bound by books and old boundaries, or will we trust that the Spirit will engage us and guide us, as we struggle with our scriptures, our understanding each other, and our various religious paths?
Jesus said the Spirit will lead us into the truth...
Shalom
Andrew
ps May I say how much I appreciate your politeness and civility. You have maintained this whilst being quite clear about your own position. Such grace is sadly lacking in much online discussion! Andrew
SharePrevious page: Prayers for the road
Next page: Are We Safe?
